ClaimRestored › Carriers › American Integrity

American Integrity:
What the FL DFS Filings Show

3,727 residential property Civil Remedy Notices naming American Integrity, 2022–2026. Ranked #3 of 435 Florida carriers by filing volume.

Check my American Integrity claim free →
3,727CRN filings naming
American Integrity
#3Rank among 435
FL carriers
6.2%Share of all FL residential
CRN filings 2022–2026
$0Cost to check
your settlement
By Stuart Nixdorff, Founder of ClaimRestored — who took his own Hurricane Milton claim from a $23,266 offer to $1,352,367 recovered. Read the case. Reviewed 2026-07-31.

What this data is

A Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) is a formal filing made with the Florida Department of Financial Services under Fla. Stat. §624.155. It puts an insurer on notice of alleged bad faith and starts a 60-day window for the carrier to cure. Every CRN is a public record.

ClaimRestored maintains a structured corpus of 60,573 residential property CRN filings covering 435 carriers from 2022 through 2026. This page shows the aggregate pattern for American Integrity. No individual filing, policyholder, or claim detail is published.

Read this before drawing conclusions. A CRN records an allegation, not a finding of wrongdoing. Filing volume also tracks market share — a carrier writing more Florida policies will tend to accumulate more filings. And roughly 99.9% of filings in this dataset were made with attorney involvement, so this is a picture of disputes that escalated, not of all claims.

Filing volume by year

YearFilingsRelative volume
2022251
20232,349
20241,039
202588

Peak year: 2023 (2,349 filings). 2026 is a partial year.

What policyholders alleged

Each filing can cite more than one reason, so percentages total over 100%.

Reason citedFilingsShare
Unfair Trade Practice3,36190% of American Integrity filings
Claim Delay3,21186% of American Integrity filings
Unsatisfactory Settlement Offer2,65271% of American Integrity filings
Claim Denial2,06855% of American Integrity filings

If your American Integrity claim feels low

The pattern above tells you what other Florida policyholders formally disputed. It does not tell you whether your settlement was short. That depends on your policy language, your documented damage, and what the carrier actually itemized.

Build your record first

Policy, photos, estimates, payments, and correspondence in one place. Track the deadlines that apply to your claim.

Compare against the data

ClaimRestored benchmarks your settlement against the 60,573-filing corpus by carrier, storm, and claim type.

Know the escalation paths

DFS complaint, appraisal clause, CRN under §624.155, or licensed representation. See how claims escalate.

Source. Florida Department of Financial Services Civil Remedy Notice public filings, residential property lines, 2022–2026. Aggregated by ClaimRestored. Carrier named as filed; corporate affiliates are counted separately. Reviewed 2026-07-31.

Questions about American Integrity claims

How many Civil Remedy Notices have been filed against American Integrity?
3,727 residential property Civil Remedy Notices naming American Integrity were filed with the Florida Department of Financial Services between 2022 and 2026 — 6.2% of all residential property CRN filings in that period, ranking #3 among Florida carriers.
What do policyholders dispute most with American Integrity?
The most cited reasons are Unfair Trade Practice (90% of filings), Claim Delay (86% of filings), Unsatisfactory Settlement Offer (71% of filings). A single filing can cite more than one reason.
Does a Civil Remedy Notice mean American Integrity did something wrong?
No. A Civil Remedy Notice is a formal notice filed under Fla. Stat. §624.155 alleging bad faith, giving the insurer 60 days to cure. It records an allegation, not a finding. Filing volume also tracks how many policies a carrier writes — a larger carrier will tend to have more filings.

See where your American Integrity settlement stands

Free AI review in 3 minutes. 60,573 FL DFS CRN records. No credit card needed.

Start free review →